By Eileen FitzGerald
(Danbury CT) News-Times
July 2, 2007
http://www.newstimeslive.com/news/story.php?id=1058256&source=tabbox
Connecticut schools will stop using an art clay that may have asbestos
contamination from the talc added to lower the temperature at which it needs
to be heated.
The state's health and education departments issued the directive, and in
response one of the major suppliers of clay says it has changed the product
it will ship to the state in the future.
Last week, the Art and Creative Materials Institute, an international
association that is an authority on art and creative materials, asked its
manufacturers to replace within six months Nytal 100 talc used in art and
craft products, according to vice president Deborah Fanning.
She said the move was made more to quell consumer concerns than it was
due to safety, and her agency did not ask that products be pulled from
shelves.
Two Brookfield residents calling for this alert are pleased with the
state's actions and hope more people will be aware of the risk of Nytal 100,
described as asbestos or similar to asbestos, depending on which labs test
it.
"If schools aren't buying this clay, this is great,'' said Kerry Swift,
who worked with Kathy Rossland to urge Connecticut to take action. "It's not
just schools that are buying it, though, other people and other states are
buying it. The Connecticut departments of health and education are taking
the lead on this, but the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) has been
totally remiss."
In the June 20 letter to superintendents, the two state departments wrote
that although there has been a debate as to whether the talc material falls
under the regulatory definition of asbestos, "there is enough uncertainty to
warrant caution when using clays with added talc."
The state health department recommends that schools inventory their art
clays and wet-wipe when cleaning art rooms or kilns where talc-added clays
are used.
"We are recommending art clays that use talc, especially Nytal 100,
shouldn't be bought for the foreseeable future," said Brian Toal, a
supervising epidemiologist for the state health department.
The state considered a lot of research, including lab results from an art
room in the Brookfield schools that had a positive asbestos test, Toal said.
In addition, he said, the state considered the result of a New Jersey
court case that found Nytal 100 talc mined by the R.T. Vanderbilt Co. of New
York was responsible for the asbestos-related cancer of a pottery shop owner
who bought large bags of the talc for his clay.
"This seemed like the right thing to do," Toal said.
The Vanderbilt company has denied that talc is a problem.
Sheffield Pottery in Massachusetts, which provides thousands of pounds of
art clay to schools in Connecticut, has changed its product in response to
the alert.
"As soon as we got wind of this, we made the decision to make talc-free
clay for Connecticut schools," owner John Cowen said.
Cowen's company will no longer purchase talc from Vanderbilt's New York
mine but will buy from a Texas company. Cowen said although he thinks the
material in the talc was misidentified as asbestos, it is similar to
asbestos and could be a health hazard.
"There is stuff coming up all the time" about Nytal, Cowen said. "It's
never going to go away. The best thing is to get rid of the material."
Rossland said the state's action to ban the product is important.
"To us, it's very exciting that they've done it. It's the start. We're
concerned about other users of the clay and the whole nation. We're hoping
the word gets out and that schools take it seriously."