Board of Directors
Robert B. Cameron, M.D.
UCLA Medical School
Nicholas J. Vogelzang, M.D.
Nevada Cancer Institute
M. Ann Abbe
Arlington, Texas
Michael Harbut, M.D., M.P.H.
Royal Oak, Michigan
Roger G. Worthington, Esq.
Dallas, Texas
Mathew Bergman, Esq.
Seattle, Washington
Susan Vento
St. Paul, Minnesota
Mouzetta Zumwalt-Weathers
Cary, North Carolina
Ulf Jungnelius, M.D.
Pfizer, Inc.
In Memoriam
Congressman Bruce
F. Vento
Science Advisory
Board
Harvey Pass, M.D., Chairman
Karmanos Cancer Institute
Victor Roggli, M.D.
Duke University
Robert N. Taub, M.D.
Columbia University
Lary A. Robinson, M.D.
H. Lee Moffit Cancer Center
Steve Hahn, M.D.
University of Pennsylvania
Joseph R. Testa, Ph.D.
Fox Chase Cancer Center
Claire Verschraegen, M.D.
University of New Mexico
Eric Vallieres, M.D.
Swedish Cancer Institute
Dan Miller, M.D.
Emory University
Raphael Bueno, M.D.
Harvard/Brigham and Women's
Hedy Lee Kindler, M.D.
University of Chicago
W. Roy Smythe, M.D.
Texas A&M
Executive Director
Christopher E.
Hahn
MARF, inc.
1609 Garden Street
Santa Barbara, CA 93101
tel (805) 560-8942
fax (805) 560-8962
c-hahn@marf.org
http://www.marf.org
|
September 8, 2004
VIA EMAIL AND REGULAR
MAIL
Russell Budd, Chairman
Baron & Budd
3102 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 1100
Dallas, TX 75219
Mark H. Iola, Esq.
Stanley, Mandel & Iola
3100 Monticello Avenue, Ste. 750
Dallas, TX 75205
Robert B. Steinberg, Esq.
Rose, Klein & Marias
801 South Grand, Suite 1800
Los Angeles, CA 90017
Re: National Gypsum Chapter 11
Victims Trust
Distribution
Plan: Ounce of Prevention Worth a Pound of
Cure
Gentlemen:
I am the Founding Director of the
Mesothelioma Applied Research Foundation (MARF), the only
501(c)(3) charity whose mission is to eradicate mesothelioma
as a life-ending disease. MARF was formed in 1999 by doctors,
patients, trial lawyers and two former asbestos companies
(viz., WR Grace and Owens Corning Fiberglas) who decided
after years of fixing blame we needed to focus more energy on
fixing a national health crisis. In 2002, we offered Judge
Alfred Wolin our expertise in assisting the Bankruptcy Court
evaluate the singularly devastating financial and medical
hardships endured by mesothelioma patients (see attached letter,
Exhibit 1).
By now, the facts are both sobering and all
too familiar: millions of Americans wake up each morning with
dangerous levels of carcinogenic asbestos fibers in their
lungs. Millions of tons of asbestos-containing plaster,
tiles, joint compounds and fireproofing continue to shed
respirable fibers in thousands of schools, hospitals,
buildings, homes and churches from coast to coast. Thousands
of lives have been lost in the last few decades because of
asbestos-induced lung cancer and mesothelioma, for which
there is no "safe level" of exposure. Asbestos
cancers are predicted to peak in the next two decades.
Meanwhile, billions of dollars have been consumed by asbestos
litigation, more than half of which have been consumed by
transaction costs. Despite the money spent and the lives
lost, and the threat that more lives will be lost because of
asbestos contamination, neither industry nor the government
has ever embarked on a serious mission to fund medical
research designed to prevent, detect, treat or cure
mesothelioma. The National Cancer Institute from 2000 to 2002
spent an average of $1.7 million per year on
mesothelioma basic and applied research, while it has
allocated billions for breast, prostate and colorectal
cancer research. MARF is the only public or private group
that is actively soliciting research grant applications whose
primary objective is curing mesothelioma.
Prior to filing for Chapter 11 reorganization, The National
Gypsum Company was a market leader in the manufacture and
sale of asbestos-containing building and insulation products.
Although the company has succeeded in cleansing its civil
tort liability to asbestos victims, its toxic legacy lives
on. Millions of tons of National Gypsum asbestos-containing
products sold over the past 60 years remain in place. The
lungs of millions of Americans continue to be infested with
asbestos fibers. National Gypsum may emerge from bankruptcy a
viable and competitive business, and its trust will pay out
much needed compensation, but what has the debtor done to
help neutralize or reduce the clear and present dangers its
legacy presents to the health and safety of millions of
currently asymptomatic potential claimants?
A Chapter 11 Trustee has a good faith duty to use ordinary
care in the management of the asbestos victims trust in the
best interests of the beneficiaries, which include present
and future, as yet undiagnosed claimants.
Traditionally, asbestos debtors' trustees have limited
their duty to the ministerial task of simply preserving the
trust while paying out claims. This has served many former
asbestos companies well. Once liberated from their duty to
satisfy tort claims, they have found a fresh start in the
marketplace. However, a legal resolution is not at all
equivalent to an end to the public health risks and ongoing
asbestos cancer epidemic for which, empirically (although not
legally), they bear actual responsibility.
As trustees, we are asking you to acknowledge a continuing
obligation to stem the tide of suffering by stopping the
disease at its source. We are asking you to set aside a tiny
percentage of the value of the trust for investment in
medical research that is targeted to help detect, prevent,
treat and cure asbestos-related cancers, such as
mesothelioma. By investing in competitive, peer-reviewed
research for a cure, in our view the asbestos victims
trustees will be discharging their duty to preserve if not
expand the value of the trust by preventing or limiting the
quantum of future asbestos cancer claimants. Moreover, by
investing in research to extend the life of asbestos cancer
patients, you will be helping reduce the medical, emotional
and financial hardships plaguing current claimants.
MARF, along with many other talented scientists and doctors,
are optimistic that a cure can be found. We believe that
mesothelioma is presumed to be "incurable" only
because there has never been a concerted effort by the
asbestos industry, the government, the insurance companies
and the victims and their lawyers to fund the medical
research necessary to cure it. Mesothelioma is certainly an
aggressive, rapidly advancing, terminal tumor. But the
current lack of effective treatments for it has less to do
with the pathology of the disease than the historical apathy
and nihilism towards curing it. Mesothelioma is not a disease
which has "defied all our best efforts" - as almost
no effort has been made to undo the pain and misery it has
wrought.
We are enclosing for your review the following:
1) A memorandum by MARF's Science Advisor, Dr. Harvey
Pass, which addresses the most promising areas of basic and
applied research which are most likely to yield novel and
useful strategies for the early detection, treatment and cure
of mesothelioma (e.g., proteomics, targeted biological
agents, immunotherapy, vaccines, anti-angiogenics, gene
therapy and other areas). (Attached as
Exhibit 2).
2) A summary of MARF's grant solicitation and peer-review
system for targeting and choosing meritorious research grants
(attached
as Exhibit 3).
3) A summary of the $1.3 million in research grants already
funded by MARF (attached
as Exhibit 4).
We would like to present to the trustees our strategy for
investing a portion of the asbestos victims trust in medical
research. We will show that an ounce of prevention is worth a
pound of cure. We believe a small allocation of the value of
the trust is a good start. We are standing by to assist you
in this much needed and long overdue program to help achieve
the primary goal of all asbestos-injured victims: the chance
to live a full life and die of old age.
Sincerely,
Roger G. Worthington, Esq.
Founding Director
Dr. Harvey Pass, MD
Chairman, Science Advisory Board
Cc: Trustees:
W.D. Hilton Jr., Executive Director
NGC Bodily Injury Trust
2716 Lee Street, Suite 500
Greenville, TX 75401
dhilton@trustservices.org
Alan R. Kahn, Trustee
230 Jack Leg Lane, PO Box 1107
Bozeman, MT 59715-0999
Walter J Taggart, Trustee
Villanova School of Law
299 North Spring Road
Villanova, PA 19085
Anne N. Foreman, Trustee
272 Riverboat Rd.
Front Royal, VA 22630
Legal Representative for Unknown Asbestos Disease
Claimants:
Sander L. Esserman, Esq.
Stutzman & Brombert
2323 Bryan Street, Suite 2200
Dallas, TX 75201
|